port of harlem magazine
port  of harlem talk radio
Black Voter Suppression, Then and Now
October 22 – November 04, 2020
ben tillman

unita blackwell

“We have done our level best (to disenfranchise Blacks). We have scratched our heads to find out how we could eliminate the last one of them. We stuffed ballot boxes. We shot them. We are not ashamed of It . . . Blacks must remain subordinate or be exterminated.”


The Fifteenth Amendment to the United States Constitution, ratified on February 3, 1870, contained these words: “the right of citizens of the United States to vote shall not be denied or abridged by the United States or by any State on account of race, color, or previous condition of servitude.” This gave the right to the ballot to large numbers of Black men for the first time in American history. The amendment omitted mention of gender. Women would have to wait until 1920. But both Black men and Black women would have to fight until the 1960s for full, fair, and effective enfranchisement to even begin.

The advent of the Black vote was met with unfathomable dread by most Whites including many members of President Lincoln’s own party which stood to benefit from thousands of new Black Republican voters. Before his assassination, Lincoln had come around to the idea that a limited number of Blacks might be eligible to vote.

White America had initially seen emancipation and the end of the Civil War as the climax of what Governor Bradford of Maryland had once called “. . . these devilish nigger difficulties.” But General Lee’s surrender at Appomattox revealed an astonishing level of hatred and disgust toward Yankees in general and Black folks in particular. A Tarheel State planter promised that he and other Whites “will never get along with the free Negroes” because they were an “inferior race.” In Mississippi, a planter predicted that “these niggers will all be slaves again in twelve months.”
Their purpose as one ex-rebel explained was to make certain that the “ex-slave was not a free man; he was a free Negro.”
If re-enslavement could not be achieved, southern leaders believed, then a state of being as close to slavery must be forced upon African Americans. They found an ally in President Andrew Johnson who told a visitor to the White House: “White men must rule the South.” Beginning in 1865 and 1866, all-White Southern legislatures started passing restrictive laws collectively known as “black codes.” Their purpose as one ex-rebel explained was to make certain that the “ex-slave was not a free man; he was a free Negro.”

As the history book, “America: A Narrative History” makes clear: “the black codes differed from state to state, but their purpose was clear: to restore white supremacy. While Black marriages were recognized, African Americans could not vote, serve on juries, testify against whites, or attend public schools. They could not own farmland in Mississippi or city property in South Carolina.

In Alabama, they could not own guns. In Mississippi, every Black male over the age of eighteen had to be apprenticed to a White, preferably a former slave owner. Virtually all black codes required that adult freed slaves sign annual labor contracts. Otherwise, they would be jailed as ‘vagrants.’ If they could not pay the vagrancy fine--and most could not--they were forced to work for Whites as convict laborers.”

As African Americans defiantly protested these measures and continued to test the limits of their newly won freedom, blood soaked anti-Black violence both buttressed and superseded the black codes. There was no form of murder too vile. No insult too subtle. No degradation too gross. No type of terror too great not to be employed. In 1866, mobs of ex-confederates killed or assaulted hundreds of African Americans in Memphis and New Orleans during race riots.

A Tennessee newspaper bragged about the slaughter: “The Negroes now know, to their sorrow, that it is best not to arouse the fury of the White man.” Despite the presence of federal troops in the South and occasional friendly congressional legislation in Washington, the noose, the torch, the whip, the pistol, and the knife reigned supreme.

There were many other race riots and massacres. ln the Lone Star State, a white farmer threatened his former bondsman. His freedom, he was told would do him “damned little good...as I intend to shoot you.” And the White man shot him. In July, 1866, three years after the Emancipation Proclamation, a Black woman in Clinch County, Georgia, was apprehended and given 65 lashes for “using abusive language” during a dispute with a White woman.

But no matter the level of wanton cruelty or the twisted insidiousness of the racially charged laws, nothing seemed to be able to completely stop the Black pursuit of land, education, and the ballot. Looking over this torn landscape of violence and intimidation, Frederick Douglass concluded that, “slavery is not abolished until the Black man has the vote.”
Their efforts to improve southern life through establishing public school systems, redistributing land, and equalizing laws, were seen as efforts to topple the house of white supremacy.
And there were reasons for hope. In December, 1866, Congress passed a bill giving Black males the right to vote in Washington, D.C. This was done despite popular referendums among White males in the city and in Georgetown, DC showing overwhelming disapproval. Massachusetts elected two Blacks to its state legislature.

Repelled by continued southern lawlessness and defiance, progressive Republicans in Congress proposed a 14th amendment to the Constitution making African Americans citizens. The following year, progressive members were able to pass, over increasing opposition from congressional foes and President Johnson, a series of “Reconstruction Acts,” which among other things, shifted the responsibility for registering and protecting Black voters to the federal army.

Majorities of registered Black voters began to appear in several states and counties throughout the South. Pro-Republican Union League political clubs began organizing among African American voters. About 600 African Americans, most of whom were formerly enslaved, began serving in southern state legislatures. Black senators and congressmen took seats in and walked the halls of the U.S. Capitol for the first time.

White southerners were disgusted at the election of African American politicians. Even though, as one Black member of the Mississippi state constitutional convention explained, “All we ask is justice and to be treated as human beings.”

Their efforts to improve southern life through establishing public school systems, redistributing land, and equalizing laws, were seen as efforts to topple the house of white supremacy. Southern Democrats alleged that progressives or “Radicals” in Congress were attempting to “organize a hell in the South” by placing “the Caucasian race” under the rule of “their own Negroes.” Undying enmity was sworn toward any efforts to equalize southern life between the races that was not controlled by Whites, particularly politics.

What followed would be decades of Black voter suppression employing such “legal” means as grandfather clauses, poll taxes, literacy tests, property requirements, and long residency requirements constituting effective disenfranchisement. All of it undergirded by Jim Crow segregation and the threat of constant racial terror and violence. The nation, including the Republican Party, turned its back on the very people who had helped win the Civil War and left them for a hostile South to deal with alone.

But nothing in American politics is certain for long. The authors of “The American Nation” took notice of a slow but perceptible shift in Black American politics beginning in the mid-1930s. “The spectacular triumph of the Democrats in the election of 1936 called attention to the composite nature of the ‘New Deal’ coalition that delivered the votes.” Among the different members of the coalition including organized labor, southern Democrats, American capitalists, liberal intellectuals, and northern big city Democrats were some African Americans disproportionately affected by the Depression and drawn to Franklin Delano Roosevelt’s promises of social and economic reforms.

As Black southern political power grew, many Whites there switched parties and became Republicans.
For Black folks in the Deep South, little had changed even as late as the beginning of the modern civil rights movement. The years of disenfranchisement hung like shroud over their lives obscuring their knowledge of their constitutionally mandated rights. Unita Blackwell, one of the gallant founders of the Mississippi Freedom Democratic Party, said that at first she did not know Blacks actually had the right to vote in her state.

After much struggle and sacrifice, the battle over the elective franchise was once again at the forefront of American politics. A victorious President Lyndon Johnson made it a key part of his ambitious “Great Society” programs. In his first message to the new Congress, he said, “I propose we eliminate every remaining obstacle to the right and opportunity to vote.” 

Responding to significant pressure from the civil rights community, he helped shepherd the Voting Rights Act of 1965 through Congress. The legislation banned all qualifying tests for registration which affected the right to vote on the basis of color or race. And it empowered the Attorney General’s office to take action against local boards of elections that continued to discriminate. As Black southern political power grew, many whites there switched parties and became Republicans. By the time of the Nixon administration, there were unsuccessful efforts to block renewal of the legislation.

Modern Suppression Tactics
& The Fightback

In June, 2013, a conservative Supreme Court “gutted” critical parts of the act. Almost immediately, several southern states and counties instituted new laws again making it difficult for African Americans and other minorities to vote by reducing voting hours or requiring driver’s licenses be shown on voting days.

It was clear to all that Black Americans, seen as the most steadfast constituency of the Democratic Party, had for some time now, become and would remain targets of aggressive voter suppression by the Republican Party. In 2016, the Fourth U.S. Circuit Court, in overturning North Carolina’s new ID law, observed that it targeted Black voters with “almost surgical precision.”

During the election of 2020, a variety of techniques are being used to prevent or at least reduce the number of Blacks who would vote against Republican party candidates and policies. They include but are not limited to making the electoral process inconvenient by changing or limiting hours or locations, instituting burdensome identification requirements, intimidating Black voters at the polls (the Republican National Committee is recruiting 50,000 poll watchers to “monitor” voting locations), or attempting outright disenfranchisement by purging voter rolls for what seem to be intentionally discriminatory reasons, as well as contriving postal slowdowns to impede voting by mail.

In 2018, Florida voters passed Amendment Four, which restored voting rights to more than a million felons who had completed their sentences, but last year, state Republicans passed a subsequent law making such individuals liable for the payment of any fines, fees, and costs associated with their prior convictions in order to get to vote.

African American congresswoman, Val Demings of Florida, called this a new type of poll tax. Former New York City mayor Michael Bloomberg raised millions of dollars to help pay off the debts of felons who have completed their sentences, making them eligible to vote.

Local Republicans have called for Bloomberg to be investigated claiming his action is a thinly-disguised bribe to get these ex-offenders to vote for Vice President Biden. Supporters of Bloomberg’s efforts say his action is non-partisan and question the timing of GOP criticism, coming just before the presidential election.

Texas Republican Governor Greg Abbott ordered the state’s more than 200 counties to have only one mail ballot drop-off site per county, meaning many such sites in heavily populated counties will have to close making it very difficult for many in the state to cast their ballots.

In what can only be called a war against voting access in the middle of a pandemic, Harris County, for example, a 1,700 square mile district that includes Houston and comprises the fifth largest metropolitan area in the country with over six million residents (40 percent of whom are non-white, and almost 20 percent of whom are African American) will go from 12 absentee ballot drop-off sites to one.

This was done says the governor’s office to enhance “ballot security.” No evidence has yet been provided that shows how restricting these locations is supposed to achieve that. A judge recently ruled against the governor but the state filed an appeal and won.

NAACP Election Protection Hotline Hotline

Several major civil rights groups are preparing for Republican-inspired polling place irregularities, which is expected to include possible violence. The NAACP has set up an election protection hotline. 

The 2020 election is about far more than the races for president, vice president, senatorial, congressional or local legislative representatives. By some counts, Americans will have to decide the outcome of more than 100 ballot measures. They will be given a chance to mold local public policy.

Issues ranging from the local minimum wage, income taxes, state laws, municipal regulations, and much more will have to be decided. Local politics is often the place where you can most readily see the force of your vote make a difference.

If you have ever complained about your garbage collection, sidewalks, or streets, now may be the best time to change what’s been irking you--by voting. And while you are studying these issues, please take a moment to reflect on the astronomical price paid by our ancestors in pain and blood to get the right that so many of us take for granted today.
Note: Thomas Mundy Peterson Video
Thomas Mundy Peterson of Perth Amboy, New Jersey was the first African-American to vote in an election under the just-enacted provisions of the 15th Amendment to the United States Constitution. His vote was cast on March 31, 1870

Return to this issue's Main Page
sign up
follow us on
facebook  instagram twitter  youtube
Advertisers | Contact Us | Events | Links | Media Kit | Our Company | Payments Pier
Press Room | Print Cover Stories Archives | Electronic Issues and Talk Radio Archives | Writer's Guidelines